KINGDOM VANGUARD
This page is machine-assisted Swedish awaiting native theological review.
Leadership Health Assessment

The Church Health Index measures an organisation. This one measures a person.

That single difference changes what the tool is capable of doing to someone, and it is why this instrument carries guardrails the other does not. A church survives a badly run congregational survey. A pastor can be ended by a badly run leadership one.

If this is being used to build a case
If a church is looking for evidence to remove a leader, this instrument must not be the route.

That is not a disclaimer written by a lawyer. It is enforced in the design: there is no free-text field anywhere in this instrument, the minimum group sizes are held in code rather than in guidance, and a suppressed group carries no scores at all rather than scores marked unreliable.

Four things this is not

Printed on the instrument, in the report, and in the terms. Not in small print, and not once.

This is not an appraisal.

It must not be used in a performance review, a disciplinary process, a dismissal, or as evidence in any dispute. Beyond the ethical problem, doing so after inviting anonymous participation will end honest answering in this church permanently.

This is not a safeguarding process.

If there is a concern about someone's conduct or safety, it belongs with your denomination's safeguarding officer today, not in a five-point scale. There is deliberately nowhere in this instrument to write it down.

This is not a diagnosis.

Low scores on Emotional Maturity and Care describe how leadership is experienced, not a clinical state. Nothing here is licensed mental-health assessment, and where that is what is needed we refer rather than improvise.

A low score is not a verdict on a person.

It is a reading of how leadership is currently experienced by the people asked. Most of what this instrument surfaces is structural — load, isolation, unclear accountability — and structural problems are the ones that respond to design.

Who is answering, and about whom?

Self and team both rate the senior leader, so that comparison is like-for-like and it is the one the report leans on. The congregation rates the leadership as a body — asking a member to score one named person on integrity is an invitation to settle scores, and most members cannot see an individual leader's accountability arrangements, delegation, or whether they rest.

All three answer all fifty. Unlike the Church Health Index there are no mode-only items here: a member's read on whether leaders keep confidences is as valid as the leader's own, and is often the more useful of the two. What changes between modes is the wording, not the question.

Why the team minimum is four

Three elders could work out who said what about the senior leader in an afternoon. In a team that size that is not a privacy inconvenience — it is the end of anyone in that church answering honestly again. Below the minimum the answers are held and reported only if more of the team completes it. Congregation stays at eight, as in the Church Health Index.

Running it with your team or congregation

Say what it is for before you send it, and say what will happen to the results. Decide who sees the report before anyone answers, and tell them — changing that afterwards is the single most damaging thing a church can do with this instrument. Do not collect names, and do not ask people to hand forms back to the person being rated. Group readings and the gap report are part of an engagement, where the scoring runs in Python against the same published rules.

The precedence rule

Any one of these makes the report lead with the leader's own care and accountability, ahead of anything strategic. Thresholds read whichever group scores lower — never the leader's own account of themselves alone.

  1. Integrity and Trust scores below 55.
  2. Accountability scores below 50.
  3. The leader and the team differ by 20 points or more on any dimension — needs the team mode.
Perception gaps

A difference of twenty points or more on any dimension is reported. The wording is fixed and deliberately even-handed: it says the two sides are not working from the same picture, and notes that the side scoring higher is the side that cannot see the difference. It does not say who is right. Only the leader-versus-team comparison is like-for-like; gaps involving the congregation carry the caveat that they rated a different subject, and are printed after the like-for-like ones so they cannot be mistaken for the stronger evidence.

Your answers are stored in this browser and are never transmitted. There is no submit step, because there is nowhere for it to submit to. On an instrument that asks a leader whether anyone would tell them if they were crossing a line, that is not a feature — it is the precondition for a true answer.

Status

Version 0.1, a draft. Not academically validated, not reviewed by Nordic denominational leaders, and not yet completed by a church. The thresholds 55, 50 and 20 are reasoned judgements about where a reading stops being a weak point and starts being the thing to deal with first — they are not derived from a dataset, because no European dataset exists that could derive them.

Leadership Health Assessment

Your reading