An instrument you cannot inspect is an instrument you should not trust.
Everything below is published before anyone answers a question: the items, the mathematics, the band boundaries, the rule that overrides them, and what this instrument cannot do. Band boundaries set out in advance cannot be moved afterwards to make a result look better or worse than it is.
Three rules, and no fourth
Dimensions are deliberately unweighted. There is no European dataset that would justify weighting one above another.
A dimension score
The mean of the items answered, multiplied by twenty, expressed on 0–100. Fewer than three answered items reports insufficient data rather than a misleading number.
The overall score
The unweighted mean of the dimensions that could be scored. Dimensions reporting insufficient data are left out — never counted as zero, because an absent score is not a low score.
Not enough information to answer
Excluded entirely, from both the dimension and the overall. It never counts against a church. Honest ignorance is not a deficiency and is not scored as one.
Six bands, published in advance
| Flourishing | 85–100 | Strong across the board. The useful work here is protecting what is working and preparing for succession. |
| Healthy | 70–84 | Broadly healthy, with identifiable weak points. The lowest dimensions are where a conversation is most likely to be worth having. |
| Stable | 55–69 | Functioning, but with real strain in specific areas. This describes the present reading and does not predict what follows from it. |
| Vulnerable | 40–54 | Multiple dimensions under pressure at once. A church reading here is carrying more than one difficulty at the same time, which is a different problem from carrying any one of them. |
| At Risk | 25–39 | Significant difficulty across most of the instrument. The priority is stabilising leadership and trust before anything is restructured. |
| Critical | 0–24 | Serious difficulty. This score does not mean the church has failed, and it is not a verdict on faithfulness. It means most of the instrument is reading low at once, and that is not a situation we would advise anyone to carry alone. |
Every instrument in this field publishes four numbers. We had asserted one of them and never worked out another.
Here they are with their arithmetic, so you can check them rather than believe them.
Ten dimensions, five items each. The congregational mode is asked 47: three items ask about knowledge only leadership holds.
Derived, not observed: 542 words across the fifty statements at 130 words a minute of careful reading, plus six seconds an item to choose, and half as much again for re-reading. It will be replaced by the median from the first real readings.
The report is computed in your browser the moment the last response is in and the anonymity threshold is met. Comparable instruments state hours, days, or thirty days.
Not the same as the anonymity floor. Worked out below.
How many responses make a reading mean something
We publish an anonymity floor — 8 in a congregation, 4 on a leadership team — below which no scores are produced at all. That answers how few responses make a result disappear. It does not answer how many make it mean something, and a church reading only the first number could run a reading with nine people and treat the output as a finding.
The finding this instrument exists to produce is a gap between two groups, and the precision of a difference is governed by the smaller group — which in a church is always the leadership. That produces the table below, and one conclusion worth having before you start: past a point, adding congregational responses stops helping.
| 3 answering about their own leadership | no congregational sample is large enough |
| 4 answering about their own leadership | 98 congregational responses |
| 5 answering about their own leadership | 17 congregational responses |
| 6 answering about their own leadership | 11 congregational responses |
| 8 answering about their own leadership | 8 congregational responses |
| 10 answering about their own leadership | 7 congregational responses |
| 12 answering about their own leadership | 6 congregational responses |
A leadership team of three cannot support a gap finding at any congregational sample size — and is below the anonymity floor in any case. With four, you would need about a hundred congregational responses. With six, eleven will do. If your leadership group is small, the honest thing is to run the reading and discuss it together rather than to score the gap.
This is arithmetic, not evidence. There is no European dataset behind it. It assumes the spread of individual answers on a five-point scale is about one point, and that assumption is doing real work: at a narrower or wider spread the balanced figure moves — 0.8 → 5 and 5 · 1.0 → 8 and 8 · 1.2 → 12 and 12. Two American instruments arrive at about thirty responses by other routes, which is a check on the reasoning rather than support for it. All of this is replaced by the observed spread as soon as real readings exist.
We will not restructure a church until it is well enough to be restructured.
Three triggers. Any one of them makes the report lead with Restore, whatever else scores low. Triggers one and two read whichever group reports lower — a congregation reporting trust at 40 while leadership reports 92 is exactly the case this rule exists for.
Leadership Health scores below 55, on either group's reading.
Communication and Trust scores below 50, on either group's reading. The lower of the two is what counts.
Leadership and congregation differ by 20 points or more on any dimension.
The same questions, put to two groups
Not a shortened version for members. Every question a member is asked is word for word the one leadership is asked, because a difference between two answers only means something when the question was identical.
A pastor can see almost every dimension of their own church from the inside. The one thing they cannot see is the distance between what they believe about it and what their people experience.
Leadership · 50 items
Pastors, elders, staff, and anyone carrying formal responsibility.
Congregation · 47 items
Three items are asked of leadership only — why people leave, where growth comes from, and three-year sustainability. A member can form an impression of those, but an impression of whether leadership knows something is a different construct, and scoring it would manufacture a gap that is an artefact of the question rather than a fact about the church.
Below eight congregational respondents the group score is suppressed, not caveated. A mean over four people plus one known answer gives away the sum of the rest, which in a group that small is usually enough to work out who said what — and an assessment that promised anonymity would have broken the promise. With a group that small we say so and suggest discussing the questions together instead.
The ten dimensions and all fifty statements
Published in full, before anyone answers one.
Christ-Centred Vitality
Whether Christ, prayer and Scripture actually shape the church's life, or are stated values it has stopped practising. Measured because a church can go on naming these practices long after it has stopped keeping them, which makes them the place where the people inside are least likely to notice a change.
- Our gatherings consistently point people to Jesus Christ rather than to our church or its leaders.
- Prayer is a genuine practice in the life of this church, not only a stated value.
- People here speak naturally about what God is doing in their lives.
- Scripture shapes the decisions this church makes, not only the sermons it hears.
- There is a sense of expectancy in our gatherings that God will act.
Leadership Health
Isolation, role clarity, boundaries and shared load. A widely repeated Swedish register claim, ranking clergy among the highest-risk occupations for exhaustion syndrome, was withdrawn from this rationale in August 2026 after the primary report was retrieved and found not to contain the figures attributed to it. What survives verification is narrower and sufficient: the Church of England's Living Ministry panel finds ministerial wellbeing driven by role structure rather than by hours worked, with 40% of the clergy surveyed reporting that they feel isolated in their ministry and 16% showing indications of probable depression.8 A reported 69% of inspected religious workplaces in Sweden received improvement demands — confirmed here only at a secondary source, and cited as such.7
- Our leaders have people with whom they can be honest about their own struggles.
- Roles and responsibilities among our leaders are clearly defined.
- Our leaders are able to take genuine time off without the church suffering.
- Our leaders share responsibility rather than carrying it alone.
- A leader here who was struggling would be noticed before they reached breaking point.
Discipleship Pathway
Whether a person can move from first visit to maturity along a path someone designed, or only by accident. Measured because Swedish survey data records religious change running differently between generations rather than simply downward — which is of no use to a church with nowhere for an interested person to go next.3
- Someone new to faith here would know what their next step is.
- We have a described pathway from first visit to mature discipleship.
- Discipleship here involves more than attending services.
- People here are being formed in character, not only in knowledge.
- Those who disciple others here were themselves discipled here.
Retention & Belonging
Whether people who arrive stay. Stefan Paas's peer-reviewed German study found church plants converting at roughly thirteen times the denominational average while losing 8–10% of members annually — real conversion growth, no net growth. He calls it a fast metabolism.9
- People who start attending here are still here two years later.
- Newcomers form real friendships within their first six months.
- We know why people leave this church.
- Someone arriving alone would be noticed and welcomed.
- Our growth comes from people new to faith rather than mainly from other churches.
Mission & Evangelism
Whether the congregation's activity is shaped by its mission or by its history, and whether faith is spoken about outside the building. Measured because European mission is now genuinely cross-cultural mission at home: in France, adult baptisms have more than tripled in ten years, and those with no religious tradition now form a large share of new adult converts.2218
- Members of this church regularly speak about faith with people outside it.
- We have seen people come to faith in Christ here in the past year.
- Our activities are shaped by our mission rather than by tradition.
- We could explain this church's purpose to a stranger in one sentence.
- We are willing to stop doing things that no longer serve our mission.
Volunteer Capacity
Whether the volunteer system works, separately from how many people attend. Volunteers in the Church of Sweden fell from over 70,000 in 2019 to nearly 35,000 in 2023, and its own research found many parishes have no volunteer strategy at all.1314
- We have enough volunteers for the ministries we currently run.
- Volunteers here are placed according to gifting, not only availability.
- We have a clear process for inviting, training and supporting volunteers.
- Volunteers here can step back without guilt when they need to.
- The work here is shared widely rather than carried by the same few people.
Communication & Trust
Whether members understand how decisions are made, whether difficult news travels openly, and whether conflict is addressed. Leadership and congregation can hold sharply different views here without either side being dishonest, which is why the instrument asks both rather than either.
- Members understand how decisions are made in this church.
- Difficult news is communicated openly rather than discovered later.
- Members feel able to raise concerns with leadership.
- Conflict here is addressed rather than avoided.
- There is a high level of trust between leadership and congregation.
Community Engagement
Whether the church is known and useful to people who will never attend it. In the UK, 76% of churches host community groups and 85% say they would expand that work with more resources.24 A Danish claim about public attitudes to the church previously stood here and was removed in August 2026: the source cited for it reports membership counts and cannot support a statement about what the population thinks.34
- This church is known and valued by people in our local area.
- We serve people in our community who will never attend our services.
- We understand the actual needs of the neighbourhood we are in.
- We work alongside other local organisations.
- If this church closed, our community would notice.
Governance, Clarity & Stewardship
Whether the structure fits the church as it is now rather than as it was, whether finances are transparent, and whether commitments are sustainable. Nominal church income in Germany is still rising while membership falls; the EKD's own published projection expects that to reverse.1517 A budget built on the current figure is a budget built on a lagging indicator.
- Our governance structure fits the church we are now, not the church we used to be.
- Our finances are transparent to those who ought to see them.
- We could sustain our current commitments for the next three years.
- Our budget reflects our stated priorities.
- We have safeguarding practices that we actually follow.
Next Generation & Pipeline
Whether young people belong rather than being catered to, and whether anyone is being prepared to lead. Succession in ministry runs on a long clock: the Church of England's own clergy wellbeing panel reports a substantial share of serving clergy approaching retirement, and no tradition trains a replacement quickly.8 A church that starts looking for its next leaders when it needs them has already started late.
- Children and young people are genuinely part of this church, not adjacent to it.
- We are actively identifying and developing emerging leaders.
- Young adults who grew up here are still connected to this church.
- Our leaders are actively preparing people to succeed them.
- Someone under thirty could hold real responsibility here.
The plainest page we publish
No score measures God's approval
Nor a church's spiritual worth, nor the faithfulness of its leaders, nor the presence or the work of the Holy Spirit. What is scored is observable organisational and ministry indicators, and nothing else. We measure what is observable and never pretend that is all there is.
It is not a validated psychometric test
Version 0.1, a draft. It has not been independently validated and has not yet been reviewed by Nordic denominational leaders. This is on the methodology page rather than in the small print, because a church deciding whether to trust the result deserves to know what it is trusting.
It is a conversation, not a decision
Not professional, legal, financial, employment, medical or clinical advice — and never the sole basis for a decision affecting a person's employment, ministry, discipline or wellbeing. Using it in an appraisal will also end honest answering in your church permanently.
The translations are machine-assisted
Swedish awaits native theological review, and the locale says so on the page. Translation error in a measurement instrument does not announce itself — it appears as a dimension that scores oddly in one country.